Saturday, May 4, 2013

Obama and Diversity?

We are troubled by the recent attacks on the Obama administration for the lack of diversity in the president's cabinet and other high-level appointments. We believe the criticism is unfair, as a cursory examination of President Barack Obama's high-level appointments reveals the following.

Overall: seven rich males and five rich females. Of these 12 rich males and rich females, two are rich Roman Catholics, two are rich Jews, three are rich Protestants, one is a rich Portuguese-American, one is a rich Japanese-American, one is a rich Dominican-American, one is a rich African-American, and one is a rich mixed northern European-American.

Now we ask you, is this not diversity?

Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Privatization?

We are liberal-left types across a wide range of issues, but we are also sociologists who care about precision in thought and language and the importance of data-based arguments. Thus, we are often at odds with colleagues who allow their ideological views to overwhelm their use of precise language and the need for data to support their views. Let us take the case of the term "privatization" which has wide useage but has re-surfaced in our community in connection with a new university president who was known for his past support of efforts to transfer government-based programs to the private sector, that is, privatization. So, we ask the following questions about privatization and would welcome responses and suggestions of things to read.

(1) What does the term mean with regard to specific social and economic practices and programs undertaken by government with taxpayer funds?

(2) What are some specific cases of pre-privatization practices and costs, and post-privatization practices and costs; for example, state owned and operated toll roads versus privatized toll roads.

(3) What are the benefits and costs of any case of a privatized government program? Who wins and loses what in the transition?

(4) What are the short term and long term projections about public and private options for useful public services? Are there limits to privatization or is the practice likely to expand?

(5) Is it important to make a distinction between the actions of local, state, and federal government with regard to costs and benefits of privatization?

In short, we would welcome a discussion of the exact meaning and costs of privatization.

Friday, January 18, 2013

The Arrest and Trial of an FBI Agent

In the turbulent 60s there was a local FBI agent who was assigned to the campus area. He was reputed to have been an Olympic-class runner in college. One of his responsibilities was to monitor protest and demonstration activities on campus. Several student members of SDS claimed that they had been told by the Agent that if they continued their activism he would contact their draft boards and try to change their draft status.

At an informal meetings of SDS members it was concluded that the Agent was infringing on free speech rights and the right to engage in public protest. There was general agreement that there should be a people's arrest of the Agent and that he should be tried in a people's court. This may sound bizarre today, but in the moment there was extensive discussion of participatory democracy and the need for people to confront established authority because it was held to be corrupt.

A plan was developed. A member of SDS would contact the Agent saying he wanted to talk with him about his activism and wanted to avoid any change in his draft status. He would offer to meet the Agent in the Sweet Shop in the Union building. The plan was that when the Agent sat down with the student other SDS members who were already in the Sweet Shop would swarm over the Agent and bring him to the lawn in front of the Union where a trial would be held. The plan went awry. The Agent came to the door of the Sweet Shop but would not enter because he didn't like the look of things. He turned and started to walk away and the remaining SDS students went after him. The agent exited the east door of the Union and proceeded to run north on Grant Street. Students gave chase but the Agent's alleged running prowess became a reality and there was no way that anyone was going to catch him.

The activists were discouraged but they decided to proceed with the trial with the the defendent in absentia. About 20 people gathered on the originally designated spot and the trial proceeded. The prosecutor was Don and the judge was Robert Perrucci. There is no memory of a defense attorney, but the jury consisted of all present. Witnesses described the Agent's attempts to harrass and intimidate them. The judge asked for a decision by a show of hands. The decision was unanimous: guilty!

ADDENDUM: Correction

There is a correction to this account of the arrest and trial of the FBI Agent. We uncovered a story in the local newspaper about this event. It reports about 100 persons at a "people's tribunal." and lists Robert Perrucci as chairman of the jury that issued the verdict. There is no mention of Don, but Jeff is mentioned. The account of the Sweet Shop incident in the newspaper matches the above account in general, but there is no mention of the foot race on Grant Street with the swift Agent.

In the search for the article on the "people's tribunal" we also uncovered a newspaper article and a photo of Robert and Carolyn at the base of the steps of the Executive building as 135 Black students are placing the bricks on the steps. Homer is prominent in the article as a spokeperson for the group.

Sometimes memory and data work together, but memory is a questionable source without supporting evidence. See Robert's article with Beth on the "Social Structure of Memory" in the International Journal of Contemporary Sociology. 

Sunday, November 11, 2012

USMC and ME

Today is Robert's birthday. Yesterday was the birthday of the United States Marine Corp. Somehow I think the connection of birthdays is more than coincidence. In 1951, Robert entered the Marine Corps. They took an unfocused, drifting, high school drop-out and gave him self-confidence and a belief that he could control his own life. Then the government finished the job by providing him with the means (GI Bill) to use his new ambition to do something with his life.

Robert wouldn't be where he is today without the USMC and the GI Bill. His second chance began with his newly-discovered blend of personal initiative and responsibility, but those individual qualities wouldn't have meant much without the GI Bill. So Obama and Romney were both half right, but as always, the truth is often at the Golden Mean.

Wednesday, November 7, 2012

ONE DAY

This was sent to a seminar on December 14, 2010.

This is a call to action. The message of ONE DAY is simple. It is a call to working people of America to take one day a week in which they and their family members will re-take control of their lives. On that ONE DAY, say a Wednesday, all will refrain from watching TV or using any electronic device such as a cell phone, computer, ipod, smart phone, and the like, unless use of such technology is required by one's employment. For that ONE DAY, through acts of self-discipline and self-denial, we will regain our humanness, for we will be beyond the reach of media, corporations, advertising, and politicians. ONE DAY declares that this act of self-discipline is the beginning of how to empower people through their recognition of a common bond regardless of the numerous differences that, we are told constantly, divide us.

What should people do on this ONE DAY with their new benefit of having more time? The possibilities are endless, but they could include solitary activities like reading a book or starting a new hobby. They could also involve joining an existing community group that one has read about and found interesting. Or they could start new community groups with neighbors, focusing on their concerns and their ideas for creating better lives and better communities. The possibilities are endless, but they will emerge from the concerns and interests of people living their daily lives and facing common uncertainty about the future.

This is not a call to eliminate electronic technology, but to make it work for us in ways that deal with our concerns. The call of ONE DAY is especially important to the tens of millions of young Americans who feel empowered by the electronic technology because it provides ties to others beyond the prying eyes of adults. But beware, because unless you take control of the nano-world you will become an insignificant click in a wired world that will control you from cradle to grave.

Saturday, October 27, 2012

New President

While everyone was distracted by the national election we acquired a new prez at our university. There has been a lot of heavy breathing about the appointment. One concern expressed is about the close relationship between the incoming president and the board of trustess involved in his selection. A second concern is about his lack of academic credentials as a former faculty member or administrator. Here is our take on the new president.

1) We have been in residence with 5 or 6 presidents at our university. Our teaching and research activities did not change one bit under any of them. There may have been some small effects on our annual salary increases related to the amount of money allocated to our college or department, but the real or imagined differences would be small, and any president would likely have done the same thing.

2) University presidents are concerned primarily with the external environment of legislatures, corporate donors/partners, and alumni as donors and supporters. They do not get deeply involved in internal matters except in times of fiscal crisis when a major reallocation of resources is required. Our university does not seem to be in a crisis situation and we would expect that future allocation of resources will continue as in the past, with the strongest programs in engineering, some sciences, and management being the most favored.

3) Our new president is more of a technocrat than an ideologue, although many of the heavy breathers would not agree. We view him as someone who likes data, and his proposals will be data-driven and thus may be contested on those grounds. Faculty will not be able to blow smoke up his ass about the traditions of higher education; he will simply listen to faculty concerns and state: this is the problem, what do you propose that we do about it.

4) Many faculty will have their shorts in a knot over the president's history with privatization and the fear that it will be applied at our university. Most major research universities, including ours, are eager to "rent" their faculty or research capabilities to corporate sponsors, but we can't see much that would be privatized.

5) The new president's lack of academic credentials may indicate that he will not undertand the norms and traditions of academic governance. That is a good one and certainly gives us a laugh. We have had the experience of working with a Dean and a President who had extensive careers in academe as faculty and administrators but who had a fondness for ignoring faculty when it didn't suit them. In fact, the Dean had a curious practice of having the faculty vote several times on the same question until they got it right.

Bottom line: The new president will not matter much unless there is a crisis that provides the opportunity for major changes. Why would anyone want to be president of a university in a crisis situation?

Saturday, October 20, 2012

Jobs for America: A Citizen-Led Stimulus Plan

This post is a follow-up to the Jobs post on Sept. 23,2010.

Current efforts to deal with the financial crisis and the recession have not been focused on job creation and hold little promise for keeping the official unemployment rate below 8 percent. While achieving little for millions of Americans who are unemployed or underemployed, the net contribution of existing solutions has been to polarize the population and increase the level of accusatory shouting. The bailout money for troubled banks and financial houses made some of them well and contributed to the bonuses of their upper-level personnel, but it had much less effect on Americans who are unemployed, or who have high levels of mortgage and credit card debt.

The immediate effect of bailout dollars for U.S. automakers were plans to close more plants in the United States and to increase production in plants overseas. And the "cash for clunkers" program appeared to work as millions of Americans traded their old gas guzzlers for newer gas guzzlers, but most new purchases were from foreign automakers. These programs not only did not benefit the average American in need of a job, but they also served to generate great conflict and public discord.

We propose for consideration a stimulus plan that can create jobs for average Americans and can do so in a way that unifies people in a belief that it serves the common good. The focus would be on America's deteriorating infrastructure of interstate highways, state roads, bridges and dams, aviation, drinking water, toxic waste sites, national power grid, public parks, beaches and recreation sites.

The American Society of Civil Engineers has provided a Public Infrastructure Report Card of conditions in 15 areas, and the grades have been poor to failing. These projects to upgrade infrastucture would not be make-work, but vital to the health and safety of Americans no matter where they live or how much money they make.

Recent high-profile disasters such as the failure of the levees to protect New Orleans from Katrina and the collapse of a major bridge in Minneapolis  provide ample evidence of the need to improve America's infrastructure. How would Jobs for America project work?

When Americans file their tax returns each year they would be invited to make a voluntary contribution of $100 to $500 to the project by adding the amount to the tax they owe or deduct their contribution from their tax refund. If 20 million taxpayers contributed an average of $100 it would generate $2 billion for the project. More than 132 million Americans file tax returns, and we believe that at least 20 million would buy into the project.

The political pressure of a citizen-led stimulus plan would require Congress to become a partner with the citizens' voluntary contributions by providing matching funds of 10 times what citizens contribute; in this example, $20 billion. The money would come from the procurement side of the defense budget (currently at $104 billion) which always has spending for new ships or planes that the military has not requested.

Infrastructure building projects would be located in each state, and when states apply for project funds to rebuild infrastructure they would have to make a matching contribution, either financial or in-kind. National labor unions would provide the skilled work force of carpenters, electricians and masons that would be at the heart of the infrastructure projects. They would be expected to become a partner by making wage and work-rule concessions to help reduce the cost of the infrastructure projects.

The project would be started by bringing together a leadership team of high-profile Americans, such as Bill Gates, Warren Buffet, and Ralph Nader, who are unifying symbols with a record of having worked on behalf of the common good. They would initiate a national public education effort to inform Americans about the Jobs for America project. Buy-in contributions would come from national advertising firms and national media outlets who would work together to deliver the message to the public.

The solution to the current economic crisis and recession will depend upon a sustained effort to create jobs in a way that calls on all Americans to share the pain and the gain. The key to restoring hope requires a combination of creating jobs and making existing jobs more secure. It is time to bring Americans together for another "moon mission," but this time we should land in the United States.